Spoken like a true beta

Story please

I had a girl for a while who believed in creationism. She knew I was an atheist, and she claimed to be looking for The Person God Has In Store for Me (tm). She would drive me crazy by saying things like, "if we evolved from monkeys then why are there still monkeys around? They all should have evolved too!"

I would rage. Like, RAAGE!

Nonetheless, she was quite attractive. Picture Diane Kruger. She liked to go out, and best of all she liked to dance. Our mutual friends were kind of square. So, on more than one occasion, I just cut her out of the herd. While they all sat around talking, I'd get her to leave with me and say to the friends: "Hey, we're going to a club. Can we hook up with you guys later tonight?"

Then at some point, after pawing her all night on the dance floor, I just escalated to kissing her. Textbook stuff. Once a girl is into it, she's into it as long as you don't ruin it. At no point did she say, "wait a second, this violates my religious teaching."

What she did say, after we had hooked up, was "are we going to tell people that we're together?" I told her I didn't mind if people know that we'd had sex, but I wasn't looking for a LTR. Now that made her mad. Fornication in violation of almighty god's commandments didn't make her mad. Being told, after having sex, that we aren't dating made her mad.

So then she tried giving me the cold shoulder. I actually asked her out - I was going to take her on a legitimate, nice date. No response. So I stopped talking too.

The next time I see her she's with three guys and a girl at a high top table outside a restaurant at a big art festival. Everybody is just walking around, having a good time. I'm with a buddy and we walk over to their table. Introductions are made. I asked her how she was. She's like "fine" so I don't say anything else to her.

And I'll never forget this part. Two girls walk by the table, and they are incredibly hot. Dressed up. Just amazing. There happened to be a cameraman there for some website. They obviously knew him, because they made some joke like they were stealing something from his bag. I put my arms around both girls and said, "I'm with security. I think you two are pickpockets. You're under arrest." They laughed.

My buddy, best fucking wingman in the world, doesn't miss a beat. He pushes me out of the way, puts his arms around the girls and says, "I'm with the FBI. This man is a known terrorist. I'll protect you." Now we had them hooked. They were into us, and we just walked away from the table with them.

At any rate, later that night christian girl texts me and we go to a hotel. This time, I really turned up the freaky on her, just to kind of establish the level of the relationship. She liked it. She liked to be given orders.

The whole rest of the time we were together, that was what characterized our relationship. She got turned on by being ordered to do stuff. In the bedroom obviously, but everywhere else too. Sometimes I would text her at work and give her something to write on a post-it note, then make her put that in her bra and keep it there until I saw her. She would be turned on by walking around with this filthy shit about her on paper against her skin all day. Simple stuff like that.

She did come back to the religious thing occasionally. She'd want me to go to church with her. I'd refuse. She would not see me on Sunday.

I think she started getting depressed. She started crying one time and I told her that this wasn't good for her, and she needed to get back on track with her faith - that was the only thing that would make her truly happy.

Didn't talk to her for a while, then she starts texting me wanting to meet up. We try it again, same thing. She's obviously not going to be happy with me, so I tell her we can't see each other again no matter what. I get a few more texts, and I'm polite but firm.

About a month later, a mutual friend tells me she's dating a loser, like some alternative punk guy. We're still fb friends though and I didn't see anything about him on there, so who knows. Soon after that, she's engaged to some guy from church. He looks like a nice guy actually. So, I truly hope that she's happy.