Been thinking about this and wanted some input from guys with more experience.
On one hand, I get that being grounded, emotionally controlled, and not getting pulled into arguments is the ideal. No unnecessary drama, no reacting, just staying solid.
But I’ve noticed something that seems contradictory.
A lot of girls seem to remember their more “toxic” exes way more vividly, the guys where there was tension, arguments, emotional spikes, etc. (They got alpha widowed)
Meanwhile, the stable, calm relationships where the guy was always composed don’t seem to leave the same imprint.
Is it actually better (from an attraction standpoint) to have occasional conflicts / tension with a woman, as long as you’re still in control?
Or is that just misinterpreting things, and the real answer is still to avoid fights completely and maintain frame at all times?

Vermillion-Rx Admin 6d ago Stickied
Have you read the sidebar?
Lone_Ranger 3 3d ago
Lots of women (most?) start fights because they NEED drama and excitement.
Do not get pulled into their world. I have made this mistake before.
I once watched a video on how to train your parrot. Parrots bite. And they bite hard. It's just in their nature. A well trained parrot does not bite, and you can enjoy handling them and teaching them little tricks.
Many people start shouting at a parrot when it bites (and it will). And they start shouting at the parrot. Of course, the parrot doesn't understand what you are saying, it just hears loud noises and notices that you are animated. The parrot enjoys this animation and will start joining in, squarking and flying around. This is usally the highlight of their day...beacuse they spend 23 hours a day bored out of their minds in a cage.
You have inadvertantly rewarded your parrot for an undesired behaviour. This parrot not only enjoys biting you on its own, but you are signaling to him that you also enjoy it, by all the shouting and animation. How on earth is this parrot ever going to learn to not bite you?
The solution is simple. The second your parrot bites you, just silently pick it up and put it back in its cage, and put the cloth over the cage. Leave it for 23 hours.
Start again the next day. They learn quickly.
The same is obviously true with women. Never reward their undesired behaviours with fighting. They say never wrestle with a pig, because you will get dirty. The pig is already dirty and enjoys rolling in the mud.
Do I need to spell it out any clearer?
You know what to do.
mattyanon Admin 5d ago
Those guys are attractive and indifferent to her.
Forget that toxic shit, she's just bitter she got dumped.
Lower attractiveness.
Tension: yes
Flights and conflict: no.
Fighting, raised voices, emotional arguments: absolutely not. This benefits her. It reduces her attraction to you. She will claim the victory even if she loses. It destroys trust and comfort, and it leads to court cases and jail time for you.
Here's how you have an argument with a woman:
You: "I am not happy that you said X, so I am now leaving".
Her: "How the fuck dare you!? I never said that! You said something else! This is all your fault!"
You: literal silence, say nothing, keep leaving.
Hey: "So that's it? You're just going to walk out? You're going to fucking leave?"?"?
You: no longer hearing, you have left.
Her on text: "If you don't answer me now it is over you fucking piece of shit"
You: nothing, no response nothing, zip, nada.
Her: more texts.
You, after 48 hours: "Let's grab breakfast"
Her: "Oh my god, you fucking asshole......"
You: ignore her for another 48 hours of this shit.
You, after another 48 hours: "Let's grab dinner".
At this point you either get "I'm sorry", or you block her permanently.
In future, count her down..... "You've got 10 seconds to take that back".
If she ever calls your bluff, you leave.
All the reasons that men do not do the above are the root causes of all problems that men have with women.
No-Stress-Cat 5d ago
I let my women know right off the bat, I will walk out that door if they fuck up. Yes, I still have to train them, and when I make corrections, it's only once: "I'm sure that you'll never let this happen again" and that's the end of it. Knowing that you have one foot out the door at the start, and that it's up to them to make sure the second one don't follow is all the tension you really need.
First-light 2 6d ago
You have something here but I am not sure it is only what the title suggests.
Having to work for it invests people more in attraction (this is scientific fact) and in that respect some fights in the early stages (while the desire is still fierce) may imprint a man harder on a woman but it has to be while the desire is fresh and the desire must be strong enough to overcome the negativity..
Women do tend to remember all the negatives strongly and when the heated rush is over, these memories will still be on the hard drive, so I would still advise that it is ideal if she has to work for it in non confrontational ways -like availability, like keeping you interested, trying to lock you down and so on.
It is also true that women will try harder for a guy they really want, who will know his value is above them and may be harder to get. An ordinary guy acting like this will just piss her off. Its important to see it from the right end of the telescope. Its not necessarily because its a great strategy for him, its because she can't let him go.
Because Chad can, doesn't mean you should (or Chad should either necessarily if he actually wants her as a mother to his children). I think this is something a lot of red pill men see form the wrong side. Can get away with and should ideally do are not the same thing.
But yeah, I still think there is something there with those caveats.
GeorgeIII 1 6d ago
There’s an element of truth to what you think.
The way I think of it, women are usually bored and boring, right? Is a fight ever boring? No.
Women also crave emotional experiences, even more than men. Is a fight ever NOT emotional? No, they are always emotional.
So you stir emotions and un-bore women by fighting. But just like @First-light said, it’s only for when they are emotionally invested in you. And too much fighting makes a relationship toxic and not worth it, whether short or long term.
…
This reminds me of something I was thinking about. Conventional RP wisdom is to not show mate guarding behaviors or act jealous around your woman. And girls will occasionally do stuff to try to make you jealous as a shit test or to see how much you like them. So normally, we say don’t show your jealousy when they do stuff like that.
I’m listening to the audio book of The Art of Seduction, and there’s a theme of making someone less bored and giving a little but not too much of what someone wants hooks them to you.
This got me thinking. Let’s say you are normally presenting yourself as an ultra stoic gigachad alpha man, who shows no emotion when a girl tries this stuff. It might actually be that when you show you are jealous occasionally, you actually stir up more attraction in your woman. That is, you could PRETEND to be jealous every once in a while to make her like you more.
In theory, you get some of the best of both worlds: you are normally alpha and your woman will usually like that. But the occasional bout of faked jealousy will make her feel you desire her, and automatically pass some comfort tests, and make her feel like she worked really hard to see that jealousy, increasing her attraction to you.
By the same logic, you could also start a small fight over something small to stir the emotional pot to keep things exciting for her in the relationship. This would also show that she can’t do whatever she wants and keep you, again also increasing her attraction for you.
The key here would be to not actually get too stirred up in the “drama” that you cause or participate in. You want to be 90% stoic on the outside, and 100% stoic on the inside.
Well, this is all just a theory. If I get a chance to test this out on the field, I’ll write up a report here. If anyone reading this has experience with these strategies, I’d love to hear about it!
Vermillion-Rx Admin 6d ago
No.....
You guys often conflate the effects of things. Fights INDIRECTLY help (IF she needs calibration that you could leave).
In statistics this would be a mediation effect. An example would be that partying leads to bad grades. Except it's not partying that leads to bad grades, it's staying up late as shit and drinking that results in bad grades. Partying --> Staying up and drinking --> bad grades. Which then statistically shows that now partying does not in of itself equal bad grades
In this case it would be Occasional fight --> he might leave/has boundaries --> attraction. When you fully account for WHY a fight might result in increased attraction, it is NOT the fighting itself.
Assuming so is going to kill relationships. A better way is to instead assert boundaries and if she doesn't fold walk. It has nothing to do with fighting. Fighting is fucking retarded. They always say don't argue with idiots because they drag you down to their level and win with experience.
Don't argue with women, they drag you down to their level and beat you with experience.
You guys need to stop hamstering the ever-loving fuck out of Red Pill and game and stick to the basics. Stop trying to re-invent the wheel
Vermillion-Rx Admin 6d ago
Yeah, and it has nothing to do with fighting (beta). The thing is these guys had other traits that women liked (mostly IDGAF attitude, tingles, neglect like going out with his boys and not responding for hours, a ton of active dread etc.)
The fighting only made her think he will leave, when he was being a little bitch by getting in fights with a woman. The fights are stupid drama. You guys are just not understanding why things work the way they do. And these "toxic" relationships never last.
Women are more attracted to men who they feel they have to constantly seek validation from. The "safe" guy who has no other options and always lets her know she will get her way all the time and that she will never have any risk of him leaving if she acts up lose attraction. Fighting only helps in so far as it simulates risk of leaving. There are better ways to cause tension like being focused on your grind about equally as having her or even a little more than her so she has to chase validation and compete with your mission, not having frame-breaking fights with your chick
Another better way than fighting to keep attraction is to look great and stay fit so when you and your chick are out she catches women checking you out and maybe even being bold and trying to talk to you. This is passive competition, because you're not even interacting with them but she can see that you could easily get pussy that isn't hers if she fucks up. Even better if a woman checking you out is bold enough to say something to you and you respond back with an everso slightly just a bit more positive than neutral reply and your girl can't fault you for it but can't ignore it either. Women need to know that other women want you but you don't have to feed into it or cheat. They just need to see that it could happen and luckily most women are so selfish that if you're hot they will eventually show interest in you because they are selfish and like to try to ruin relationships with your chick
These fights are frame breaks and the girls eventually leave because these fights wear down the toxic asshats too. Then they act like little bitches and lose their relationship. I wish some of you guys would stop looking for RP "exceptions" and think more critically about indirect effects of things that "work" instead of thinking that these things in of themselves help
Hugo_The_Great 2d ago
Looking back on my last LTR the fighting only increased attraction because the fighting was really just me looking for anything to end that LTR over and gaslighting the shit out of her when I got triggered over something irrational and making it all her fault in a very convincing manner.
It worked only because I was actually contemplating to leave her if she didn't make amends (for something small she did and I made 5x as big) and because she was already very attracted to me/there was a power imbalance. And because when we weren't fighting I'd be very sweet toward her. Yes it was a super fucked up dynamic.
Wouldn't recommend, makes for a shit relationship long-term.
Vermillion-Rx Admin 2d ago
It "works" in the technical sense but it definitely doesn't work overall.
If it genuinely worked it wouldn't result in so much mutual unhappiness and eventual split. It is a very peace-free and harmony-free way to get more impulsive emotional sex but it is shit for long-term stability and actual peace