Hello everyone. I will try and keep it simple.
Long story short: have a LTR, early on she admitted that she sabotaged some of her previous relationships, we recently rebounded from a breakup (me fixing it), but I still feel there's a lot of negativity pinned up inside her.
This negativity shows through many outlets and is generally undefeatable. An example: tonight we were talking on the phone and she was telling me how she feels spoiled for living a good life and having a good job; one thing led to another and as I try cheering her up (I proposed that we can meet and do some activity that she likes) she just says "there you go again... you're trying to fix me. If you wanna do something, then you can go and do it by yourself.". I explained to her that I derive happiness from making those I care for happy and she rebuked "so you're trying to make yourself happy?". There were other such remarks and I just told her that we should close the phone and maybe talk tomorrow.
I know there are many red flags here and we should end it, but I wanna string it along a little more and try; no, when she's not into this negative state she isn't disrespectful; she's a naive early 20s girl.
What suggestions do you have for these moments? I was thinking agree and amplify or just opt out for the day ("let's talk tomorrow"). What do you think are the causes? Initially I suspected that it was the fact that she might have high estrogen levels (a well endowed natural chest) and is also on contraceptives (doctor prescribed them).
Will be awaiting your thoughts brothers.

akatsukirp 8y ago
Less behaving like her girlfriend, she's being really disrespectful. She's lost tingles, break it off, ghost and read the sidebar.
R3v4mp3d 8y ago
We're both from Eastern Europe. It was a great relationship and it slowly faded as we each focused more on our jobs. She's a good girl with a decent father as a role model. She has her own luggage (insecurity, pessimism) but I can deal with it. The only side that I can't deal with is the negativity since it seems that being positive just doesn't help. I used to know most of the sidebar since I was an avid reader of TRP, but I stopped reading roughly 2 years ago (a few months before the relationship began) since I just had too much on my plate (had to read technical stuff for work and working on a side project).
I wanna save it since it was a really ok relationship and I really like her body.
gamecubefan95 8y ago
Then do what he told you to do
akatsukirp 8y ago
Bro, I've been there, with a depressive GF. You can't fix her, it doesn't get better. You're settling for an "ok relationship" and her body. You've lost abundance mentality, and you probably aren't taking great care of yourself because you have become codependent with her. You already broke up once, learn to let go and know that life get's better. No more rationalizing shit, time to move on.
creating_my_life 8y ago
Her happiness is not your responsibility.
R3v4mp3d 8y ago
True. My mistake was being honest about it I guess. I really do enjoy making those I care about happy. Maybe in her case applying dread might make her happier (subliminally).
juliusstreicher 8y ago
No, your mistake is trying to make her happy, when she's not unhappy. When she calls you on it, you start cackling like a BP!
A TRP axiom is that when women complain, they don't want advice etc..., they just want a man to listen.
Further, she is bragging, and you're saying "I'll stop you from feeling bad, because I'm a White Knight"! She isn't bragging to have you interfere, she's bragging to get validation!
Get to the sidebar.
creating_my_life 8y ago
dude, some girls (and people) are just broken. you can't help someone who won't help themselves. You have one life to live, focus on YOU. There are good women out there (high value). Find one.
R3v4mp3d 8y ago
This is one of my greatest flaws: my "be a decent human being" kicks in and I wanna help out people that I feel/ realize would truly benefit from it. This happens with men more often than with women, but in both cases it's not accepted and generally not appreciated. I'm trying to teach myself to abstain from it but I feel horrible seeing when someone is banging their head against a wall and I just have to sit there and watch.
With her specifically, there were moments when she just gets fed up with the bad thing and starts working out (to improve her body), learns (to change her job), tries to eat better (again body), or wants to go out and do stuff (so that she has more fun experiences). In those moments it's a joy to just bask and go along with her positivity since we synch up. But eventually the bad ones come.
vandaalen Endorsed Contributor 8y ago
Stop eating from your thrash bin and next. There is a reason you broke up. Once you crossed that line there is no way back.
caucasianinasia 8y ago
My favorite scene that demonstrates how crazy they are: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1zrLq6zW3UI
[deleted] 8y ago
[deleted]
akatsukirp 8y ago
Although you're right that women sometimes just want to dump about something and not have a guy try to fix it. There's way more going on, more red flags on both sides. Not just some isolated conversation.
R3v4mp3d 8y ago
The thing is she wasn't disrespectful for the sake of it. She called me that night to talk and I could feel it in her voice from the moment she said "hello" that something was wrong. Soon after that I asked her what's wrong and she started telling me that she feels that she's spoiled and doesn't appreciate her current life, and then she went on to tell me about other people that are leaving much more stressful or hard lives, etc. . This has happened many times before: she was sad about a fight with her parents, about feeling too unengaged in her boring job, about liking/ disliking how her roommates acted regarding certain events, etc. . When one of her "depressive moments" come up, whatever I did until now was shot down; it's like she becomes an emo/ goth chick for the next 4H/ 1-2 days with regards to everything, not just me. My post is regarding what should I do in such cases: should I just dodge it out and call her in 1-2 days or wait for her to call me with a happy tone? Should I dread/ agree-amplify/ bait and switch/ etc just to try to move the idea in her head in a different direction/ to a new idea?