So, as I was on my way to work today, an idea came into my head.
I had had a very over-protective mother growing up and as far as I can tell, women are more protective of their sons than their daughters. I have a just-so explanation (no data, so caveat emptor) for this. It also jives with my experiences as an adult man when dealing with my mother.
Mothers coddle you to ensure you're enough of a man to go off on your own. Much like a girl you date feels like she has to take the reins if you're not leading, because she freaks out without someone leading, your mother is the same way.
Essentially it's a way to try to protect you from the world, until you're ready to be on your own. Of course, she's going to test you constantly, try to keep you from doing it - it's dangerous. Only a real man should do it. And if you're a real man, you'll do it regardless of what she says.
The problem is that in modern society with absolutely zero male influence, this is often delayed or even completely abandoned - leaving you forever in her eyes as a child.
So for younger TRPers, just treat your mother's coddling like a shit-test (coddling is distinct from sound advice, but that judgment is up to you)

RedPillSafe 11y ago
Beta traits are directly tied to an excessive attachment to the mother.
MGTOW is the process of separating from the mother and becoming a man.
One cannot "grow up" until one separates from the mother and the corresponding needy emotions that are involved.
A man who never separated from his mother will be a beta in marriage.
[deleted] 11y ago
[deleted]
RedPillSafe 11y ago
Your mother will always love you because women love their children.
Just be aware of her hamster... it's the "Ah Ha" moment when you realize how your mother thinks that initiates the separation.
You can still love your mother, but do so as an adult who understands that she too is a woman.
AWALT
There's nothing wrong with realizing your mother is a woman.
TheOneWhoWokeUp 11y ago
It is important for there to be a strong father figure to encourage the kids to challenge their comfort zones and play more on the dangerous side. If you look at the interactions parents have with their kids just the way fathers play with their kids is greatly different from mothers. This type of play that fathers have with their kids is much more "adventurous" and expands what the child knows. The mother is there more to nurture and part of that is preventing you from getting hurt in the first place.
The influence from your mother is telling you the stove is hot and you shouldn't touch it, the influence from your dad is letting you touch it and learn the lesson first hand.
tenthirtyone1031 11y ago
I can partially relate but I think this is only a partial.
I grew up with a narcissistic mother and grandmother, a doormat, enabler father.
Something I had to deal with as an adult was recognizing I had been trained to put other people's emotions before my own. I still battle with it but it's some surreal shit.
Case in point, last weekend I was hashing out kid stories with my therapist. I was asked "What could have changed about your childhood for the better" and everything I was listing were things I could have done to affect other people. Not action, management of other people's emotions or my actions could have served those emotions better.
Red Pill has been great for obvious reasons. I've been benefiting from the lessons for a long time but I still find old programming that needs fixing from time to time.
My point is that the relationship between a narcissistic mother and a son is very different. Especially if there is a golden child and the son becomes a scapegoat and the father is a beaten down beta.
That protection is abuse. It's not a shit test. A narcissistic mother is protective in-so-far that they maintain ownership of the child. A scapegoat son is the way a narcissist channels all their insecurities. It's a split between SG and GC. SC is the outlet for bad they ignore - it's put on you. GC is the outlet for vicariously re-living their life.
Rfvthn 11y ago
Having been raised in a similar situation and also currently hashing out kid stories in therapy.. very well put.
TomHicks 11y ago
That is not coddling. That is helicopter-parenting. That is sheltering.
trpiece 11y ago
I'd say it's the opposite. They are more protective of girls. Be home before 9, who's the boy you're talking to?, Don't do this/that you might get hurt... ect. I'd probably attribute this to the whole victim complex, women are always the victims.
I can see how coddling may be a form of shit test for the son to see if he's ready for the real world, or at least he has to break through the shit test/rule and go on his own. Definitely a valid point.
redbluepilling 11y ago
No, that sort of protective behaviour is the result of male influence. You see fathers saying this to their daughters or mothers saying this to their daughters if that strong male is around in the household (or the mother had that type of father for a good influence). Otherwise, you usually see the 'cool mom' type that drinks with their daughter and encourages hypergamy.
Surf_Or_Die 11y ago
I think you're reading way too much into it. Sure, an overprotective mother isn't a good thing but it's not a shit test. It's human nature. You are her offspring and billions of years of evolution is telling her to protect her offspring - her only shot at immortality.
thisjibberjabber 11y ago
I'm not sure about that, but here is a related idea:
Teenagers' hostility toward parent is often them trying to build an "independent adult" frame when their parents are (maybe for good reasons) not ready to see them that way.
I am reminded of being annoyed by my Mom being overly generous with e.g. food after I'd moved out. It seems ungrateful, right? but in this context it makes some sense.
[deleted] 11y ago
Buddy, LIFE is a shit test.
[deleted] 11y ago
You're reading too deep into it.
Mothers will always be protective of their genetic legacy.
Deaddpooll 11y ago
Fuck you man!
At least spare your fucking mother! The only woman in the entire universe who'll lay down her life for you.
Keep her away from this Trp shit.
[deleted] 11y ago
NO U
Ah the classic, "all mommies are saints" play.
Can we keep YOU away from this shit, you fucking concern troll?
Rfvthn 11y ago
You don't know every persons situation. Or mother. I hate the all mothers are saints trope.
Deaddpooll 11y ago
Does the mother seem like a bitch to you in this specific case?
Rfvthn 11y ago
No, does OP? I'm not the one using profanities. Ya seem easily angered. Keep yo frame tighter.
cocaine_face 11y ago
Well, she didn't let me outside (not an exaggeration, I was very rarely allowed outside and had the cops called on me when I left of my own accord) until I moved away to college at 18. Even then, for the first year or so she'd call constantly and even tracked me down in a fraternity meeting (without knowing where I was) because she couldn't contact me.
I frequently did not have enough to eat as a child, I had to stay with relatives or in a cheap motel, or even out of a tent because she was constantly evicted and leaving her job. The house was constantly a mess - at one point we had nine cats and shit all over the floor.
She was married to a crackhead for 15 years, and one time I was dragged to a crackhouse.
She owes everyone in my family money, and not too long ago charged a $2000 bill in my name (using my SSN), and refused to pay even a dime of it until I cut her out entirely. Even that was only $50, after 8 months of me cutting her out. She once lied and told me my grandmother would pay me back if she defaulted on a loan to her, and when I called my grandmother to confirm that and she denied it, claimed I wasn't her son.
So, fuck you, guy who doesn't know about my situation and is telling me not to call out my mother.
I was severely abused for nearly 20 years, and while I hate the victim mentality many people have (and I don't), I assuredly don't want to hear "respect your mother" from a guy who is probably a punk ass middle class kid with a nice life and a picket fence.
Fuck off.
Rfvthn 11y ago
You replied to the wrong commenter dipshit.
cocaine_face 11y ago
No, it was intentional. You seemed in on the conversation, so I wanted to include you too (I assumed that's how reddit works - this is my only account and I've only had one for a few weeks)
I don't mean for you to fuck off, you're cool.
Jessie_James 11y ago
Yup, this is the truth.
Friendzone is like being in a relationship with your mother. All the love, caring, doing things for her, but zero sex. That is why women all think BP guys are so great - it's like having a little child around, but it would be horrific to have a sexual relationship with a "child" like that.