So I've not seen a romantic comedy in a long time, but the other day I caught part of one as a friend was watching it. I'm lucky she was heavily invested in it because I was finding it very uncomfortable to watch. Simply because the main Male character was so... Inconsistent.
In Romantic comedies the main character shows signs of being an Alpha (Generalization for arguments sake, some are wimps). Good looking, confident, distant, well-presented, subtle. Yet they also send cute morning messages, flounder under the main Females gaze, send gifts, talk about being love and other stuff that simply drives girls off in real life.
Yet in the RomCom the girl needs the guy so badly, everything revolves around him and
The opposite happens whenever I see or hear something about Anime. For some reason the Males are pathetic, whiny, childish, completely lacking in confidence. Yet for some bizarre reason almost EVERY female character seems destined to fall for the overly loud and annoying main character because occasionally ~He does something badass~
So in Anime the opposite is true, but the negative influence is still there.
RomComs the guy starts off manly but BluePills it up as he gets committed.
Anime the main character is a loser 23/7, 1 hour dedicated to not being a total embarrassment to mankind.
Just something I was thinking about, would like other people's thoughts on this.

HolographicWhaleTail 12y ago
Was never too into anime but do you all remember Yu Yu Hakusho? Kid was a badass.
vicious-cycle 12y ago
I once heard a saying, I know it sounds kind of Beta, because I suspect it was written by a woman, but I think it explains the RomCom inconsistency and why the male characters are so inconsistent. Remember, these are fantasy's written and marketed almost exclusively to women:
"Every woman wants a bad-boy that is good only for her, and every man wants a good girl who is bad only for him."
Its essentially female wish fulfillment....."taming" an alpha and turning him beta because she is of such high value.
This is also why RomComs make most men recoil in horror, because the instinctively want nothing to do with the concept.
OsoFeo 12y ago
In porn, hot women freely give away sex to the male protagonist. In romantic comedies and romance novels, desirable men freely give away their commitment to the female protagonist. And so the sun rises in the east again...
ExamplePrime 12y ago
Its funny because that would make sense of why certain 'nice guys' I know would be all over RomComs. When they've convinced themselves that's the right attitude they buy into the movie themselves
KyleTFH 12y ago
Modern anime is disgustingly beta. The male leads are all indistinct losers with no personality, so designed in order that the lowest-common-denominator audience can self-insert themselves into the story, and fantasize about being surrounded by rainbow-haired girls who all look about nine years old. It's basically the same thing as Twilight, but for guys. And it's very, very unhealthy.
Japan has totally lost the plot on how to be masculine. Part of it is reactionary; a lot of young Japanese guys grow up with basically no father, and their betaness is a reaction to the lousy attempts at masculinity by Bubble-era salarymen (who think that working thirteen hours six days a week and kissing up to the Boss makes them Real Men.)
I think that part of this is that Japanese guys don't aspire to emulate powerful, masculine men (Fist of the North Star, Dragon Ball, etc.) any more; they think it's too much work to improve themselves. As a result, stories where an Ordinary Lame Teenager falls into the cockpit of an experimental robot/arms of a beautiful girl/ancient magical power are much more popular.
tallwheel 12y ago
You're mostly referring to the late-night broadcast "harem" anime - which is mostly what I watch anyway. Yes. You are right on, and this has always been my assessment as well. It sells because it plays into the fantasies of the primary viewership.
homosexualsaipian 12y ago
i could honestly say anime destroyed my life and made me into a complete beta.
ByronicAsian 12y ago
But fuck is it not cathartic and awesome.
[deleted] 12y ago
I believe there is a big difference between genres just like in mangas. Shonen genre (dragon ball, naruto, lots of robots and shit like that) is for adolescents, most of the time cheesy, stupid and totaly BP.
The genre for adults is seinen (monster, blame!). Characters are not mainly children, and themes are much more refined. Those comics could be equal to books.
[deleted] 12y ago
I like how you said modern anime. Fist of the North Star was fucking aweeesommmmee!!!
atatatatatatatatatataata!
xD
[deleted] 12y ago
Read some Manwha. The koreans value manliness.
If you want an example of how a male orientated romance should be done, try Unbalance x Unbalance.
[deleted] 12y ago
I've read that. Its pretty good.
Although, I suspect Koreans value arrogance and confidence over manliness. But I haven't been to Korea so I dunno.
KyleTFH 12y ago
I might check it out. I'm not very familiar with Korean comics (or Korean stuff in general.)
homosexualsaipian 12y ago
author of that manhwa also makes bluepill garbage but other manhwas' authors are pretty decent. Young Koreans have not declined to the point of Japan yet.
[deleted] 12y ago
Such a shame too, especially since Japan used to be one of the most powerful and masculine countries on earth.
cat-tasrophic 12y ago
Do you think the fall has to do something with the disolution of the Empire of Japan after WW2 and the following occupation by Allied forces?
I mean, GA MacArthur had this to say about Japan in the 50's...
It really sounds like the United States rocked Japan so hard that we turned them blue pill.
And as for their military...
The UN basically tells Japan where they can and cannot take their military. I think that's pretty beta of Japan to take it (not like they have a choice).
I imagine that if a country's military is beta as fuck, the rest of the culture is probably worse. And Japan has to ask permission before leaving the house.
enticingasthatmaybe 12y ago
No one really knew what the US was capable of prior to WW2, not even the US. Wars are won by the anvil, not by the sword, and the US has the power to summon an apocalyptic war machine.
Japan went all in against an unknown foe and lost. The concept of modern global politics is the only thing that allowed for Japan to retain any form of their culture at all. Had they lost a full out war with an outside nation in the feudal ages, their culture would have been replaced. In many ways, I personally believe this would be the best scenario for everyone in the long run.
I would bet that Gen. MacArthur knew exactly how to "blue-pill" Japan. It's the same tactics used by our government now to keep the sheep in their pins.
I find it amusing how red-pill sociopaths use blue-pill indoctrination to maintain power.
[deleted] 12y ago
Pretty much, yeah. Back in the day, there was a strict honor code, as well as a strong comeraderie and sense of purpose among the military. Men were devoted to a higher cause.
Now? Now we have grass eaters.
KyleTFH 12y ago
True. I don't think a resurgence is out of the question, but Japan's going to have to go through some real trauma to get there.
TaylorWolf 12y ago
There are some anime that showcases redpill truth.
Gurren Lagann changed my life. The extremely red pill leader character gets the girl to fall for him, (and everything else he wants) and the beta bitch main character has to deal with it, and learn.
He eventually grows up to be the new leader and personifies everything the original dude was.
KyleTFH 12y ago
I have seen Gurren Lagann. You're right, that's a solid show. But anime is so dominated by ordinary-high-school-boy-who-falls-in-love-with-his-sister-and-middle-school-aged-roommates that it's getting pretty gross.
TaylorWolf 12y ago
There will always be good ones and bad ones. You can't talk shit about TV shows like Breaking Bad because trashy reality shows are the norm.
The sister stuff in anime can be weird but some are pulling it off. I'm watching a new one "no game no life" right now and the brother/sister dynamic is jokes. They are basically like a married couple with nothing sexual. They even sleep in the same bed cuddling. The dude has a real love interest also, and she is all jealous of his relationship with his sister. It's pretty funny and genuinely harmless.
Xein 12y ago
I gotta call bullshit on this.
Two of the most popular animes in recent time (Naruto and One Piece) are nothing like that. They're pretty much about working hard, being the best, and going after your dreams/passions.
Naruto was really good. The whole series was about pushing limits, training hard, sticking to your word or way of life, and never giving up. It was also funny b/c the main character's love interest thought he was annoying as shit and was totally in love with the douchey and aloof guy because he was naturally talented and good-looking.
KyleTFH 12y ago
Yeah, I thought about mentioning those two - but both comics started in the late nineties, and though they're still very popular today, they are ultimately still much the same as stuff that was coming out in the nineties, and new stuff coming out tends to be a lot different.
The comic magazines like Shonen Jump that are aimed at teenage boys are, as a general rule, not so bad. They do tend to emphasize strong, heroic characters, getting stronger, and that sort of thing. Rather inversely, it's the stuff aimed at older guys that tends to constitute the worst trash.
homosexualsaipian 12y ago
those animes are shounen animes, which are aimed at little kids and has tons of actions. usually heroes/main character is a badass and romance is kept to minimum.
it's when you get to teenage/adult shit. That's when we start seeing fucked up garbage.
Zackcid 12y ago
No, they are exactly that. In fact, One Piece is probably the most beta anime I've ever laid eyes on and I'm at ep. 300 something right now. A true disgrace, the sexism inside sickens me to no end. My eye catches how the creators put in so much effort to make sure that female characters absolutely NEVER get hit or hurt (by a male). One piece loves to bring in crowds, but within the crowd, you'll find nothing but clueless, monotonous, identical males who get their butts kicked in 2 seconds. Where do females at? Nowhere. Females are "too precious" for the roles of disposable background characters.
One piece seriously pissed me off so much, I'm tryna stay up to date with its releases, but I gotta take regular breaks to cool off from all the bullshit.
Oh yeah, and other than Zoro and Smoker, can you name me any character that even comes close to being RP?
Fuck_off_Mr_Lehey 12y ago
I've enjoyed Attack on titan for this reason. Death comes unexpectedly and with zero fucks given for gender
Zackcid 12y ago
Exactly. Just kinda lame how slow the pace is at. Been waiting almost a year for season 2 :(
RedSunBlue 12y ago
The whole Monkey D. line is fairly masculine except for Luffy himself, who seems to be some kind of asexual Peter Pan type character.
Luffy's dad is a revolutionary and the most wanted man in the world/universe.
Zackcid 12y ago
Yeah, I had just reached that point in the story where they reveal that his dad is Dragon (I think that's what they call him) and his dad is a Marine Head. Shit started getting serious!! But then I got bored by all the fillers, so I'm on a break right now watching Hunter X
Gol D Roger. Can't wait to see the story behind that!
[deleted] 12y ago
Don't you just hate it when super masculine men father beta as fuck kids?
In Urdu there's a sayin which literally translates to, "A saint begets a devil, and a devil begets a saint."
Basically, there's a generational jump in the personas.
JP_Whoregan Vanguard 12y ago
Consider the target audience. RomComs are written for women. And what do women seek? The "perfect guy" who can satisfy both sides of her Alpha Fux/Beta Bux hypergamy. Their version of a unicorn, if you will. That's why you see the main male character acting like an aloof, confident man one minute, and buying her flowers and writing poetry the next.
TheRealMewt 12y ago
It's important to keep in mind who writes RomComs, who draws Anime, and who their audiences are. By and large, they appeal to the "this loser is you" demographic created by even more "this loser is you" artists indulging in some wish fulfillment. At least in Anime, that can be chalked up to cultural differences between what is considered a real man in Japan in contrast to western society.
It's been common knowledge for a long time that Hollywood paints the wrong picture when it comes to how a man is supposed to woo a woman, but think of the kind of people that live in this world - hell, just look at how the rest of Reddit views TRP. If someone made a movie starring a protagonist modeled after TRP, I can imagine the audience going "eww, why are we rooting for THIS asshole?". It's what happened with I Hope They Serve Beer in Hell, so now we get more beta white knights in our movies. It's why more harem anime shows model after Tenchi Muyo than for Urusei Yatsura.
[deleted] 12y ago
Don Jon is a mostly "red pill" Rom com, and though not anime Battle Royale's is a good film from Japan.
[deleted]
[deleted] 12y ago
No shit so is fight club
[deleted]
[deleted]
[deleted]
[deleted]
[deleted]
[deleted] 12y ago
Don Jon is better than most, but the overall is message is poor. He ends up with a post wall, "go ahead and jerk it", woman who doesn't inspire him to change. Also, this conversation is far to intelligent for people to label TRP stupid.
[deleted] 12y ago
I think you over analyze. Sure in Don Jon she's older but he's not a bitch and the entire theme if the movie is him changing from a masturbatory bitch to an autonomic man. Either way nothing has to be perfect 100% in agreement.
redpillwolf 12y ago
I think in context of TRP, RomComs and Anime help to normalize societal/romantic cognitive dissonance experienced by the viewer out in the real world, men and women included.
It's like a numbing agent that let's you ignore real societal narratives, in favor of how things play out in the fantasy worlds (i.e. your head).
I say this as a guy who really loves anime and struggles to accept this part of myself along with my other "normal" hobbies like lifting and camping.
Clauderoughly 12y ago
Those sort of Anime are aimed at girls anyway, so the guys are wimpy losers.
I preferred ones like Ghost in the Shell, which had more complex stories.
tallwheel 12y ago
No. He is definitely referring to the "harem" type animes for boys.
Actually, in anime for girls, the guys are either pretty boys, or alphas (physically). They all act pretty alpha, though, in that they are very sexually aggressive and confident.
http://kamigaminoasobipsp.up.seesaa.net/image/e97da4a81bae2b7916cda5fc3d5d9a41.jpg
[deleted] 12y ago
[deleted]
Clauderoughly 12y ago
I liked the two series, they had really slow pacing but really hit hard at the end.
PaulRivers10 12y ago
Interesting thread, but which rom coms are you talking about?
Watch The Notebook from a blue pill perspective and you could think he's blue pill - he sends her a letter for 365 days until he finally gives up when he doesn't hear back, he takes her out on dates in romantic scenes, etc.
Watch it from a Red Pill perspective and he's complete dark triad. When he initially meets her she's on a date with another guy, which doesn't stop him at all from pursuing her to the point of recklessly grabbing onto the ferris wheel she's on with her date and putting himself and other people in danger. He's not being red pill romantic, he's being a sociopath - and that's what does it for her.
When he comes back he's engadged to someone and so is she - preselection for him, and kinda sociopathic for him to keep aggressively pursuing her.
You might think "oh, but he wrote her a letter every day for a year! so blue pill!" - it's not a coincidence that in the movie, she's never received those letters. After he tells her, she finally "discovers" that someone else was hiding them from her - the characters reality was complete dread game, he left, and never said anything to her. Her discovery just makes it ok for her to like his dread game "Oh, it wasn't his fault".
Another mistake is not following the sequence of events (this applies to most movies, not the notebook).
Blue Pill:
Red Pill:
Blue Pill thinking is that bringing her flowers will make her attracted to you. Red Pill thinking is that (depending on the girl) there's nothing wrong with giving her the social things she wants to feel good about herself after she's sleeping with you.
That's what I think. Blue Pill is trying to "earn" her affection with flowers and stuff, Red Pill is rewarding her affection with flowers and stuff. (Though again it greatly depends on the girl.)
ExamplePrime 12y ago
I think you're actually touching on something that I was expecting people to mention here but haven't really.
The way I see it though a lot of the stuff done is borderline beta, and because it's done by - quite often - natural alphas, there doesn't seem to be a problem.
And to be honest I've generalising a lot, I've seen very few RomComs and the few I have don't remember very well.
PaulRivers10 12y ago
Lol, yeah, I agree I've noticed the same thing...
Dreamtrain 12y ago
Anime is a Japanese export and as such, is incredibly influenced by its society/culture. Even if some things are universal such as AFBB and AWALT, culture plays a huge role on it.
[deleted] 12y ago
[deleted]
homosexualsaipian 12y ago
Black Lagoon is alpha as fuck....
Astronauts 12y ago
Honestly I think a lot of this media is responsible for blue pill behavior in general. Most "friendzoned" guys are young, impressionable nerds with little experience in female interaction but lots of absorbed training from anime, movies, TV, games, etc., wherein the main character often gets the girl because he's a paragon of justice and she "falls in love" with him for whatever fucking reason. So you have these kids talking to girls and getting really confused as to why they're being rebuffed and why girls are calling them creeps, when they're just doing what they were told would work.
I mean, it even sounds good. Just do good things and be a nice guy. Girls will see how good you are and they'll want to date you. Problem is "do good things" and "be a nice guy" are defined differently by the two parties.
SlickJamesBitch 12y ago
The only really good romcom was 40 year old virgin.
TaylorWolf 12y ago
I have a soft spot for "Couples Retreat"
Wedding Crashers is prolly the best of all time tho.
Johnny10toes 12y ago
It was funny sure but BB finally got his post wall whore err wife.
Favorite quote:
How did you know she was a tranny?
Because her hands were as big as André the giants and her Adam's apple was as big as her balls.
SlickJamesBitch 12y ago
Who is BB?
Johnny10toes 12y ago
Beta Bucks
SlickJamesBitch 12y ago
I gotcha.
ilovemyself101 12y ago
I've found close to all Anime are "beta" one of my favourites which is 'RP' in the sense of finding your goal/passion and going for it which also suggested by another TRP'r here is 'One Piece'.
The main character, as well as the rest of the crew have their own goals and work insanely hard overcoming challenges to reach their 'goal' or progress towards their 'end goal' and its entertaining and funny as hell to boot. I highly recommend it.
[deleted] 12y ago
lol its fucking Japan. What do you expect? They can't have teenage boys acting tough with teenage girls. The toughest main character in Anime I've seen is Kurosaki Ichigo, from Bleach. But its not a romantic anime so he has no idea his friend is mad/stalker-level crushing on him.