Asking fellow RPW. My partner and I have been together for almost 2 years we both have very traditional values as what men and women are supposed to be doing in the relationship however I am having a hard time with his disbelief in monogamy. I get that sex isn't emotional for men as it is for women but he says that he can have casual hook ups when he is out of town and he still loves me and it doesn't change how he feels about me. It crushes my self esteem and I don't know how to handle it. Is this a common trend for all HVM that are into the red pill theory. And btw we have an amazing sex life so that isn't the issue it's he said he just may feel the need for variety and a it comes with the territory dating a man of his status and its just sex for him
This community was created as a harbor for RP minded women whose goal is to build a lasting and happy relationship with a great man.
Created by LuckyLittleStar

[deleted]
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
I completely get it if he was a super wealthy man with all the resources in the world i would understand this concept more. Dont get me wrong he does well for himself but he doesn't have a high social status he makes 80-95k a year at best and is not the sole breadwinner I still have to work as well. And he isn't offering to marry me or take care of me....he has said he will take care of me but that I would still have to work.
pearlsandstilettos 4y ago
Advice must benefit the woman. Removed
Hodgekin 4y ago
This is a perspective of a man, 31. (Edit: I'll just add in, I'm an average man. I understand what a HVM is and how that can affect their perspective.)
My perspective may be unique, I don't represent all men.
I don't care if he wants to justify cheating with things like, men are biologically wired to spread their seeds, or it doesn't affect their attachment. Cheating is wrong. Period. That's where you should draw the line.
Now to give you some counter arguments and my thoughts overall.
1`st, having a biological desire does not mean it's good or bad. People are biologically wired to seek dopamine. That's why we have addiction. Guess what, addiction isn't good. It doesn't matter if you want to justify it by saying you have a biological urge to do it. Behavior void of morality isn't good. You need behavior based in morality; not biological urges.
2nd. Men are not as emotionally attached. That's true. But it doesn't mean they are completely unaffected. For the men who choose this lifestyle of casual sex. You degrade women as casual sex partners, but you also degrade yourself. There's no value in a person who can't control their sexual prowess. The value comes from his ability to have multiple partners, not in actually having multiple partners. Sleeping around shows lack of control, loyalty and commitment. All traits that are more valuable than looking attractive and getting multiple one night stands.
3rd. Women cheat on men emotionally. Men cheat on women physically. I'm 100% sure, if he actually loves you, he would not want you to cheat on him emotionally. I don't condone cheating, so don't do it as revenge. But it shows that he hasn't thought this through. If he's going to allow himself to cheat on you physically, he should allow you to cheat on him emotionally. If he does allow this, this shows he doesn't care about you and you are replaceable to him.
4th. Don't be the person who condones this sort of behavior. If you allow him to cheat on you with no consequence, you are condoning this behavior and have no right to complain about it. Don't reward people for bad behavior. Don't enable him to have consequence free casual sex. He's probably doing this because his past relationships allowed him to get away with it, maybe you're his first and he's testing his limits. I don't know. But you ought to teach him that you're not a push over and you have morals.
5th. All that said and done, you need to really consider to stay or leave. Even if he says he won't do it. The fact that he brought it up to you means he wants to do it. And now you'll be in a relationship where you can't 100% trust you partner when he leaves out of town. Do YOU want to be in a relationship where you don't have 100% trust in your partner? Are you OKAY with doubting every minute whenever he's at work? That takes a toll on people and will drive you insane. Don't put yourself in that sort of predicament.
Cenniii 4y ago
Just my 2 cents but HVM that want to care for you don't risk giving you Stds at such high stakes.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
That has been my rebuttal as well. He states that he never will he always uses protection. And doesn't engage in oral.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
Thank you for your perspective. For your #2 no he would absolutely never want me to even be friends with another man. He doesn't consider casual sex if it happens to be cheating as we discussed it before we even attempted to do this LDR. He states that's He is basically just masturbating with another woman's body to get off. He doesn't openly tell me about these casual encounters I asked him if it has happened since he has been there and he told me. He came to visit in December and we discussed things and he hasn't been with another woman since last August.
[deleted]
pearlsandstilettos 4y ago
Religion is not RPW advice. Removed
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
Thank you for your advice however we are both non believers. I am more of a spiritual believer and so is he. But I do believe that maybe he needs to do some shadow work and inner work on himself.
sunflowergirls85 4y ago
OP, why do you treat yourself this way? Don’t you know there are many other men in the world?
Let me ask you a serious question. If you had a daughter, is this the kind of man you would want her to date/marry?
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
I would say probably not. But it's easy from the outside looking to say this. I am in love with him and when we are together everything is perfect. I just sometimes think he overhypes how great he is to keep me interested because that's what TRP tells him. That if I see him as my best option I will do whatever and put up with anything to stay with him because I'm 36 and approaching "my wall" I'm a very loyal and committed person willing to make things work for the person I love.
SunshineSundress 4y ago
I find this to be generally true. Men can compartmentalize sex easier than women can. Many men can definitely love one woman, and have no-strings attached sex with another without any indication of his feelings for the woman he loves. The same is generally not true for women, which may contribute to why this situation immediately feels so alarming.
That being said, it doesn’t really matter if it’s true or not. If non-monogamy is something that you are unable to deal with or feel good about, I think you two have a clear difference in goals and values, and a pretty big incompatibility. It will not be easy to navigate, and the hit to your self-esteem may make you unable to be a good partner and will make you question your relationship’s security.
I don’t necessarily see this as infidelity, because he’s being transparent with you about what he wants in a relationship instead of going behind your back. Even so, unless YOU can make peace with his views on non-monogamy, trust will be hard to maintain, and a relationship without trust is almost certainly doomed.
Again, is it reality that high-status men who have more options are more likely to exercise those options? Yes. Is it true that some women who are with high-status, high SMV men are more likely to accept non-monogamy on his end? Also yes - and it would be naive to think that some of the wives of HVM are not turning a blind eye to their mistresses and side pieces. For some women, they would rather be in that position with a highly attractive man and reap the benefits of being their main woman.
But can YOU be that woman? If it just doesn’t feel right to you, then listen to your instincts, and perhaps consider that there is always tradeoffs when it comes to picking a mate. If you would rather have loyalty, maybe a high-rolling playboy bachelor isn’t the best option for you. There is a reason why we suggest RPWs vet for a man with a mix of good alpha/beta traits.
Side note: I’m mildly wary of a man who has to tell you about how high status and high value he is. It should speak for itself and be fairly obvious to you if it were the case. When he has to speak about it as a selling point for what he wants, it seems like he has to inflate his value to convince you that he’s worth it. If he were truly as high value as he’s trying to make it seem, you would have already accounted for it yourself and it would have been a major consideration that YOU chose to factor in when confronted with this situation.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
I agree with a lot of what you are saying I also agree that the fact he continues to always tell me he's statistically higher than average and so high value that he's over hyping himself.
LateralThinker13 4y ago
A high value male doesn't have to tell you he is such. He is, demonstrably, high value. Any man who claims to be, probably isn't.
SunshineSundress 4y ago
Glad it’s resonating with you. Maybe you should spend some time to consider what YOUR goals and priorities are, and whether they align with his. If they don’t, maybe you two are just not compatible.
The women who consent to non-monogamy are usually the ones who are VERY aware of their partner’s high social status and value and attractiveness, based on their own observations. They decide that they are okay with non-monogamy because of this awareness. If you didn’t come to this conclusion without him constantly reminding you about how statistically special he is, I don’t know that it’s enough to sway you on such a big decision. And that’s not even taking into account the potential incompatibility and disparity in goals and values.
blueberrypanda1 4y ago
You are right that it’s possible for some men to have unemotional sex with random women. That doesn’t mean it’s what men should aspire to.
People - both men and women - who want polygamy or open relationships tend to be narcissistic/ selfish and and not make ideal partners IMO.
Monogamy is harder and yet it builds a deeper connection in the long run. There are enough high-quality men who want a monogamous relationship. If you want monogamy do not settle for a man who does not. IMO the best men want monogamy.
SunshineSundress 4y ago
Who am I to tell all men what they should or shouldn’t aspire to? It’s not my place to moralize about anyone else’s life choices or goals, because I’m not going to be the one who has to live that life.
That is a perfectly reasonable opinion for you to have for your own life. But there is no one-size-fits-all definition of an ideal partner for all women. Some women are hell-bent on getting the most powerful and successful man in the room, or the field, or the city, or the country. If that’s what’s her idea of an ideal partner is, then she may have to face the reality that those men are more likely than the average joe to want (and to achieve) non-monogamy in their lives.
Absolutely. This is what I told OP in my comment, and why I suggested that if loyalty and monogamy are a priority to her, her vetting process should incorporate looking a man with green flag alpha AND beta traits.
Again, this is a perfectly reasonable personal opinion but is also subjective. The most accurate definition of a HVM I’ve seen is “a man who is good at successfully achieving his goals.” However, the right HVM for you is one whose goals are compatible with what you want from a relationship. The best man for you may very well be a man who wants monogamy, but the best man for an extremely hypergamous woman may not be. Again, it all comes down to what we as individuals want, and not generalizations about what should be.
[deleted] 4y ago
I’m not saying this in a way meant to offend. You can find a LVM that has less options and more open to monogamy. You are not going to change your SO’s mind and some of what he’s saying IMO is true(the idea of casual sex not necessarily being an act of love and more “sport”.
But if you aren’t ok with this it’s better to move on. His mentality, it’s likely a matter of time before he exercises his options and I appreciate his honesty at least. Most dudes are cowards and wouldn’t, and even lvm cheat.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
I agree that it's just sex he is in the military and overseas I was already open to him not being monogamous while he's there because it's just sex. My concern was that he recently told me this behavior would continue when he returns back to the state and that is something we never discussed pr agreed upon.
kneesofthetrees 4y ago
For me, this is grounds for a very swift breakup. Whether or not he has cheated is besides the point; you hold fundamentally different values, and accordingly, you will never fully trust him. Do not try to change him, as it will likely not get you anywhere but will breed bilateral resentment. I just do not see any possible way to reconcile this difference.
emmalai85 4y ago
I understood ethical non-monogamy, and was willing to offer it to my husband. He didn't take me up on it, until over a dozen years of being together, and then after we tried it, he decided that it wasn't a good idea for our relationship and we are monogamous by choice.
I'm very open minded, and I read what you're saying and I'm just gonna nope on out of it. Don't do this. He's not being ethical, he's not being honest, he's over-valuing his worth.
He's not giving you any commitment, or security, that would make playing with fire even worth touching.
There are plenty of high value men out there, who don't think cheating or being with other people all the time is worth it.
It does damage if you're not wired to be in an open relationship, and that's what we found out - that neither he, nor I, like to share, and it hurts us both. So we decided not to do it.
But we didn't do it from day one. We did it a dozen years later and a lot of communication and conversations on what we would do if things went wrong or it wasn't for us. I was willing to leave our relationship over it. I love him, but not at the expense of my emotional health. Sharing him that way, was not worth my sanity. And, he feels the same way about me. Which is why we could experiment, and still be together, because we were on the same page. You two are NOT on the same page.
You don't want this. You shouldn't accept it.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
I really appreciate your advice. I agreed to the non ethical monogamy while he is away overseas but was under the impression that it would end when he returned and we are back together, as we are in a LDR right now. Up until recently he has said he may continue these habits if he goes away on a trip after I am already invested into this relationship 2 years down the road.
emmalai85 4y ago
You're allowed to have boundaries.
He's allowed to do what he wants, but disrespecting your boundaries like this comes down too - can you accept he treats you this way? Do you need this as a boundary? Or is it a deal breaker. Only you can decide what is a deal breaker.
In my case, this attitude towards my feelings would make me nope on out of the relationship.
2 years is not very long in the scheme of a lifetime. You haven't lived together for those 2 years, the emotions are real, but your shared experiences are not very much at this point.
i would bail, and find someone who sees you as worth more than he apparently sees you.
[deleted] 4y ago
[deleted]
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
I am doing my part as being submissive, friendly, feminine and fit. This ideology is just all new to me and the first RP man I have ever encountered this is all new to me.
nemma88 4y ago
Just as not every woman is cut out to be a mate, not every man is cut out to be a captain, and RP men could struggle more than BP men - especially those treating LTR as casual STRs. The RP men sphere doesn't give men much self improvement advice in this area, and is hyperfocussed on STRs meaning they might not be good LTR prospects. Maybe he's missed out on reading, or is deliberately ignoring comfort . We can nudge, advise and if we're committed we may go down with the ship.
But you're not married and the ships being steered into the rocks.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
I feel silly asking this but what is STR?
nemma88 4y ago
STR is Short term relationship. So focusing on skills and methodology for casual sex and relations, to maximize attractiveness for the initial meeting period. This is the vast majority of RP men conversation.
LTR is Long term relationship. A different set of skills with some overlap, but exclusively holds theories relating to comfort and security needs. These are brought up sometimes but are not the main focus of discussion.
[deleted] 4y ago
[deleted]
pearlsandstilettos 4y ago
RPW is not automatically trad.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
And we aren't typical traditional but we do hold very similar values on traditional roles of men and women. I am very open to make thinks work for me and him just trying to find a common ground and looking for advice.
pearlsandstilettos 4y ago
And all of that is fine and reasonable. The issue was with the person responding to you that he's not trad and then her advice springs from that. RPW works if you have a good man, it doesn't matter if he's "trad" or not. As you say, some ideas overlap but we don't dismiss people for not being traditional enough.
[deleted] 4y ago
[deleted]
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
It may seem dead end to you from the outside looking in but the way he looks at me and treats me when we are together suggests otherwise to me. I believe what he tells me as far as wanting me to be his lifelong pertner.
[deleted] 4y ago
[deleted]
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
I really do appreciate you advice a d I am taking everyone's into consideration. I may eventually decide to walk I am doing a lot of self discovery at this time but as of right now it's just not that easy for me to throw in the towel and say goodbye.
Fat_cunt27 4y ago
Sorry but he sounds awful
_Pumpkin_Muffin 4y ago
So this man with very traditional values:
What is traditional about that? What's so "high value"? I hope he's at least insanely hot.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
Lol not insanely hot. What I mean by traditional values is he wants to be a provider, protector and take care of me. I said I was ok with the casual sex while he was in another country since we are in a long distance relationship at the moment.
LateralThinker13 4y ago
When he's around, and not deployed out of country dicking other women, you mean. You may as well move to Egypt, because you're in denial.
_Pumpkin_Muffin 4y ago
You said you would be ok/"turn a blind eye" with casual hookups, but you'd be uncomfortable with him sleeping multiple times with the same woman. Which he did. Behind your back. You can set whatever boundaries and expectations you wish in your own relationships... and that's what he violated. Sorry OP, he's a cheater. Cut your losses.
Anonymous_fiend 4y ago
From a religious perspective casual sex still affects men. Adultery was a capital punishment for a reason. Polygamy was only allowed as a necessary evil in Judeo-christisan religious to protect women and kids as starving to death was pretty common (and there's more women than men). And back then marriage wasn't for love it was more of a financial and practical agreement. Men don't carry the same risks that women do (pregnancy, difficulty decompartmentalizing, and higher levels of bonding through sex) but I disagree that it's 100% meaningless. But my views on sex are more than just physical. It's true HVM can find someone who is ok with this style of relationship. Not all hvm are non monogamous (and not all lvm or average men are monogamous) it's just that hmv have the abilty to exercise their options. He could also find a bi woman who is open to threesomes. If you aren't ok wirh him sleeping around then don't waste any more time with him. Love isn't what makes a marriage last. It takes similar values and compatability. That's why vetting is so important. What's compatable for you may not be a very alpha noncommittal man. A mix of beta and alpha traits is ideal in a husband and father imo. He seems pretty clear that doesn't want a monogamous relationship. Take a man at face value. You can't force him into it. That's a deal breaker for me but if you aren't religious it doesn't have to be for you. If you'd rather share him than be with anyone else then a don't ask don't tell type of arrangement may work...as long as he keeps it discreet to not embarrass you, doesn't impregnate any of the side women, takes care of your needs, doesn't bring home any diseases and respects any established boundaries. At the end of the day can you handle this? Or will it destroy your confidence and make you resent him? This is a choice you need to be certain about. Was he very upfront about these views in the beginning or did he wait to spring them on you after you were already emotionally invested? If he wasted your time by leading you on to believe he wanted a committed monogamous marriage that's unfair. And cruel. If he told you and you stayed well that's on you.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
He has said that he doesn't want marriage. He was married prior but he has also said that maybe he will change his mind in the future. We are in a long distance relationship now he is military. And I stated that I was willing to turn a blind eye if he had some one night stands. But not if he has sex on a regular basis with the same person. I recently found out that he had sex with the same woman 4 times and now he's telling me that he may or may not be monogamous in the future when he returns to the states that he could do it again or he may. Ot ever do it again...But he wouldn't throw it in my face. As far as impregnation he has had a vasectomy but I didn't find out about that until the 1 yr mark. He never told me. I'm 35 he's 42 i am at the point where I am unsure if I want children I wish he would have told me that before I vetted him for a year I found out he had a vasectomy on reddit. And his response was he wasn't going to tell me because it was a Trump card if I was to end up becoming pregnant implying I was going to cheat on him.
Jenneapolis 4y ago
This info really needs to be in your initial post. It changes the whole perspective on the situation when he’s already cheated on you and lied to you vs how it initially appears just that he is asking for non-monogamy.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
I agreed to turning a blind eye to his fidelity while he is away.
Jenneapolis 4y ago
I guess that’s just depends on how you define your boundary of him not having sex with The same person multiple times because it sounds like you said a boundary of not the same person over and over and he is sleeping with the same person over and over (4 times you know of). Even by ethical nonmonogamy standards, this is a violation of a set boundary. ultimately only you know what you are comfortable with but it feels like you are making excuses for somebody who’s not being honest about multiple things with you.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
He said he won't do it again. And if he slept with someone more than once he would tell me so we could end things. But at this point I don't believe him.
amadexodus 4y ago
First of all, OP you really need to break up your super-sentences with periods so it’s easier to read your posts.
Second of all, this guy has more red flags than I can count.
Dump this man immediately.
JadedByEntropy 4y ago
So many dangerous lies
Anonymous_fiend 4y ago
Yeah he's not being truthful and not respecting boundaries. You can't have a healthy lasting marriage like this. He's been very manipulative and purposely misleading. The vasectomy part is the biggest red flag to me. He either wants monogamy or doesn't there's no maybe he'll change his mind in the future. He's not a HVM he just follows rp strategy to get what he wants. This kind of man isn't a good fit for someone who wants marriage. Unfortunately this is what happens when someone waits until the odds are against them to find a husband. Most men are taken, playing the field like this, or "undateable" aka too low value/on her level/average. He wants the benefits of a wife/marriage and the benefits of being single. And he's just not that into her. Finding a hvm who wants to provide and have children (bc geriatric pregnancy/low fertility) when in your mid 30s is very rare. Her time is precious she shouldn't have stayed 2 years when there was so many red flags at year 1.
golden_eyed_cat 4y ago
In my opinion, there's a difference between a High Value Man and a Highly Desirable man, and as red-pilled women, we shouldn't conflate these two types.
OP's partner might be highly desirable, but he lacks the qualities to be called a high value man.
Anonymous_fiend 4y ago
100%. Being attractive with dark triad traits makes a man desirable but not high value. Proper vetting is so important to make sure you don't marry a wolf in sheeps clothing. Hvm is about social circle/network, ability to provide, looks, personal traits (like leadership) and character. People look up to and respect hvm.
free_breakfast_ 4y ago
Going against the grain here, but dark triad traits are simply a different set of goals and different set of environments that favors those behaviors and strategies.
This is obviously not OP, but there are women who are not looking for marriage and find strong compatibility and shared goals with some men who are 'dark triad wolf'.
Introduce a collapse scenario (massive inflation/depression, sudden disruption to our western supply chain, or a civil war) - and you'll find that these 'wolves in sheep's clothing' are going to be fairly competent and capable in out surviving 'HVM' who have 'strong social circles, ability to provide, leadership, and character, and that people look up to and respect'.
I'm not disagreeing that those traits are going to be what the majority of women will want in their LTR in modern society. But the dark triad (Machiavellianism, psychopathy, and narcissism) would instantly flip flop to 'HVM' not only in attractiveness but also survival values and goals outside of the bubble of relative 'safety' that we experience in most western societies.
There's obviously going to be a large variety of men who are operationally coming from somewhere other than dark triad who can survive collapse scenarios, but don't cast judgement on men for having their own set of goals, values, and will to live. Discernment is a better tool, because one can never know how the future will turn out.
[deleted] 4y ago
Can I be honest with you?
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
Please
[deleted] 4y ago
Him hiding the vasectomy from you, at your age(don’t take it personal) where you are getting close to really needing to decide whether you want to have children, then blaming it on you, is a HUGE dick move and red flag.
The monogamy thing he’s being upfront with so like I said in another comment, you just need to decide if you can handle it. But I wouldn’t be surprised if there are other situations of manipulation where it’s him just being a coward and not being upfront. I think you really need to analyze how messed up this is. Imagine if you found out years later and you wanted kids?
The only proper response would have been to apologize or if he’s against saying I’m sorry, owning up to it. This shows a huge lack of character to me.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
That's what I'm realizing. I'm not sure if I want kids but I would have liked to know from the get go that he was incapable and I wouldn't have even continued a relationship with him. He also said that from his past experiences women have ghosted him after he told them so now he just doesnt.
[deleted] 4y ago
So basically “I’m not honest because I don’t want to deal with a consequence for a decision I made”.
You already said if you knew this you would not have continued your relationship with him early on. Idk what HVM is really worried about keeping women bc of a vasectomy or him not wanting to have kids. There are plenty of women out there that don’t want kids nowadays or at least believe they don’t. He needed to give you the ability to decide whether this was something you wanted to pursue long term, if he decided you were more than a hookup(which he did).
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
My thoughts exactly.
Lando_620 4y ago
First your post & comments are a pain to read, use punctuation please. Second, it sounds kind of like you already know what you want to do...to stay with him. Your post & comments acknowledge his read flags, most of which he openly stated to you...yet you defend him in a manner that suggests you came here looking for validation in continuing the relationship not advice on what to do.
Ultimately, if people don't want to change don't waste time trying to change them. It won't happen. That leaves you with one choice, to accept what he told you and stay...or decide you are not okay with it and leave.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
I appreciate your advice. Sorry about the punctuation. You may be right maybe I am looking for validation because I love him and don't want to leave him. I am just afraid that in the long run its going to be detrimental to my mental health.
trashy615 4y ago
Your mental health is worth more than his sex life.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
This is true but if he is such high value and getting so many women why does he want me? And why does he make efforts to come see me as much as possible, plan virtual dates and even discuss our future plans and life together.
trashy615 4y ago
A man who refuses to be monogamous is not high value in my opinion.
kneesofthetrees 4y ago
I agree wholeheartedly. Also, value is in the eye of the beholder. A person’s morals should factor strongly into one’s value judgements of potential partners. Even the most “high value” man on paper is repulsive to some small fraction of women.
LateralThinker13 4y ago
Why do you assume he's high value?
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
This is true maybe he's not...but to me he is.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
But he claims high value men are above 6 feet tall, have abs make money. He's a marine he's not Jeff bezos.so he's not a billionaire with a Hiram of gold digging twenty year Olds swooning over materials. He thinks he is though
trashy615 4y ago
A mans value is not measured in height, abs, or financial prowess. I mans value is measured in his character, his desire to provide, and his standing in the community.
Your BF sounds like a narcissistic boy, that's overdosed on REALALPHAMALE nonsense.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
Like I said I'm new to TRP and he claims a RP man and highly desirable and HVM have those things.
free_breakfast_ 4y ago
OP.
There's a star rating system in addition to an 'endorsed contributor' tag next to each commenters name.
Zero stars like mine or no tag can represent someone who is new and unfamiliar to TRP and RP praxeology.
Use the star system / endorsed contributor tag (5*+) as to what the community actually endorses.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
I want to thank all of you all for giving me strength and advice its something i need....I lost my mom in 2016 to colon cancer and went through depression and an abusive relationship. I do not have any females in my life to turn to for advice. I am afraid I'm settling for this relationship because I don't want to end up alone and my self esteem took a hit in my prior relationship.
Noressa 4y ago
This is a hard admission to make. And you're right, it's hard to end what mostly feels like a good relationship to something that seems so minor compared to say, abuse.
There are a great many men out there who would respect your boundaries and work with you towards your goals, without hiding vital information for over a year! Yes, hiding the vasectomy, especially for that long, is completely disrespectful.
Reach out here if you need to, try to find some friends closer as well. He's giving you no absolutes on the thing you have stated is important to you.
Takiyah7 4y ago
Please read the book Fascinating Womanhood (check the group description) and get therapy.
The book gives relationship advice from a traditional perspective and the therapy is to help your self-esteem and any lingering battles you may still be having from your depression and prior abusive relationship.
Your responses concerned me greatly
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
I tried to find that book but there are several different editions on my kindle. Which one??
Takiyah7 4y ago
I think there should be a link to it in the group bio. The one I'm reading is a borrowed online version because I'm really broke right now
fearofgodd 4y ago
From a male POV i can tell you that he can be real about that. I'm a man and I love my wife, but my sexuality is something I can't risk. Women never wonder why their men get fat, loose hairs, and became "weak". This all about our hormons, money and self-confidence. And knowing that we still in the game is a huuuuge booster you can't find anywhere else. Obviously the majority of modern women don't understand this and you can see where males (and indirectly women) are at now : avoiding engagement, fearing responsabilities, swapping roles, sharing 50/50... I'm 32 and i experienced more things then the majority here, so if you don't agree, i respect it but this above is my truth
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
We are both in agreement about staying fit and in shape so we are both attractive to each other. I do t believe that people should use marriage to get complacent and lazy like most do. My sex drive matches his perfectly and there is no disconnect there. I just can't give him what he needs while he is away and we are doing long distance. And I also don't want a roommate who splits roles 50/50. I enjoy women duties and I want him to do men duties.
beepincheech 4y ago
I’ve read through your other comments. This is VERY obviously a dead end relationship and you should have realized that early on.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
I can see how it comes off as a dead end relationship. But if it was dead end why would he spend his time, money and resources to fly to the states to see me and make plans about our future and continuously tell me he wants me. And agree to having a long distance relationship and make virtual dates with me regularly?
beepincheech 4y ago
Because you are convenient and comfortable, for now. He probably does care for you on an emotional level, to some extent. But it will never be enough to marry you or even be faithful to you. If you stay with him it will go nowhere and you will inevitably become very bitter and resentful. That’ll be when he decides you are no longer convenient and comfortable.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
So I am sure you can see my dilemma and confusion.
LateralThinker13 4y ago
If he's military, flights are cheap. As are words. And maybe you put out?
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
We have been together 2 years of course I put out and he has had to pay for every trip and he's flying from Japan. But if he's banging so many women over there why come pay and get it from me when he can get it for free over there??
Noressa 4y ago
Because you represent stability and are attractive enough to him that he doesn't want to lose this. People can do lots of things from a place of relative safety and stability. Like.... find other relationships to eventually move on to, because whenever they feel bad, they can fall back on their comfort, then move on.
Meanwhile, if there's someone afraid to lose something, they try to do more to make themselves more appealing.
With that in mind, what do you want? Do you want kids? Do you want monogamy? Do you want marriage?
If he doesn't meet these and they are important to you, break it off and find someone willing to invest the time and resources into things you value as well.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
He has said that he doesn't want to lose me... I am a great catch fit, friendly, cooperative a great cook, never been married and have no children and I have a good job.
crater01 4y ago
I’m going to repeat the questions she asked you:
You said he doesn’t want marriage, and he probably doesn’t want kids either. Even if he’s spending money to see you, it might be because you’re one of the only women he knows that would put up with him sleeping around when he’s deployed and also back home. I know a lot of military wives that would leave so fast in that situation it would make your head spin.
So in my opinion, you’re wasting your time. This is clearly affecting your self-esteem and ability to look at things objectively. Maybe you’re deeply insecure or in love with him, maybe you feel like he’s the best you can do - whatever it is, I would encourage you to snap out of it.
Talk to other women who dated men in the military as well. Military men have a certain reputation, and a 43 year old divorcee who says he never wants to get married again and now wants an open relationship with someone sounds, honestly, just about right. It’s like the perfect opposite to the stereotypical military man who gets married at 18 and has 5 kids with his high school sweetheart. The cycle continues lol.
My boyfriend served and we were in an LDR for a while. He never made me feel insecure during the time we were apart. Granted, he never wanted a non-monogamous relationship, thank God. My view is that many people who attempt a no-strings attached poly relationship end up with a broken heart and a bunch of emotional baggage IF they are not wired for it already. If I were you, I’d cut my losses while I can. He’s older, more established, and he’ll never budge about this, and the only thing I foresee you gaining is a massive emotional hang-up after this.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
Marriage isn't a huge deal for me not something I need. I just want some type of commitment and stability. I don't want to wait 2 years for him to return and put all my eggs in one basket for a man to just up and leave me. Kids....eh, I go through phases were some days I do and some days I don't. Monogamy while we are living together is a must when I am providing him with everything he needs sexually...I grew up in a military town a.d have dated another military man who was not this way. TRP is a whole new theory I never knew about until him
crater01 4y ago
If he’s saying there’s a chance he might want to sleep with other women even if you’re already doing everything for him when you’re together in the states, then you’re barking up the wrong tree by asking for stability from this guy. He doesn’t sound very HVM in my opinion. Maybe possibly RP but I don’t even think that of him; if he was like a typical RP guy, he’d leave no ambiguity concerning commitment.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
Right, he would just continue to live the bachelor life and spin plates and not even have a relationship with me
crater01 4y ago
Exactly. The fact you’re not even asking for marriage and you also are sympathetic to his desire of sleeping with other women while he’s deployed shows you’re really not asking for that much. If he can’t give you the bare minimum that you want, then you can surely find a man who is a much better match for you.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
Agreed
Noressa 4y ago
Which is great, but what do you want?
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
I want to keep him and be happy but I cannot tolerate him being unfaithful when he is here in the US and I'm providing him and fulfilling him with everything he needs. He said as long as I do those things he may never sleep with another woman again, but he doesn't want to lie and say that it may never happen again.
Noressa 4y ago
Keeping him is just one aspect. Does he meet any of your other long term life goals.
You said he "may". That doesn't inspire confidence. If you want monogamy, this isn't the man to do it with.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
All of our other life term goals align.
Noressa 4y ago
It reads like a dealbreaker for you, and I wouldn't advise putting energy into a "may".
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
That is a good answer i have done that with other dead end relationships in The past and wasted way more years of my life.
MuttonDressedAsGoose 4y ago
Some people are not monogamous by nature. I know men and women who feel that way. And you don't have to agree with them. You don't have to accept it in a relationship.
While I do think men are more likely to feel inclined to variety, it is not something that you have to accept in a partner. But it is also something that you cannot change. This guy is telling you what he expects and feels justified in doing. At best you can guilt him into lying to you about staying monogamous.
There is a concept called ethical nonmonogamy. It involves transparency on all sides - with every partner - and informed consent for all. There is also a conscious recognition of any power imbalances and an emphasis on fairness. For example, if one partner demands permission to sleep with others but cannot tolerate the same from their partner, that's not fair. And people who are ENM know that it's not for everyone.
Bubbly_Window_6719 4y ago
He sounds like a selfish person, out for his own good only. And that is ok - but you deserve better! His selfishness needs to be addressed.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
He said that it's not being selfish and I can walk anytime I want. I chose to be with him and this is what I get for dating a HVM
Bubbly_Window_6719 4y ago
What he says is irrelevant, facts!
A HVM is subjective and in my eyes a person who is unable and unwilling to commit to a partner is very very low.
Advanced_Bar_673 4y ago
Hi there! F 44, I have recently introduced transparent non - monogamy into my relationship (2 yrs), for my boyfriend (M 44). I want to offer some suggestions, but I'd like to caution that I believe these options should likely only be explored with a partner who DEFINITELY sees you holding a permanent place in their life, as the potential for anxiety and heartache on your side is probably huge if you don't have the emotional security you crave in your relationship to explore these.
(For the record, this was not an easy decision for me, and I posted here as well as talking to a therapist and good friends)
My bf and I had several calm and lengthy discussions about our sexual needs and wants in the relationship, and although I prefer to keep our relationship closed and exclusive, I "get it" logically that he craves variety.
So, I drew up a Hall Pass system (subject to change) to try and meet in the middle. Now, I think I have more security with my guy than you do yours (he said he would not end our relationship if I ultimately decided the Hall Pass system doesn't work for me), but I wanted to try this because I want him to lead a fulfilled life, and I genuinely believe he needs this to feel "optimized" in a LTR.
Some of the boundaries include: *All activities transparent and above board. I personally cannot entertain a "Don't ask/ don't tell" policy.
It's all a work in progress, but having an open, calm, and honest discussion about everything has truly helped me feel less anxiety and unsure. Of course, nothing is ever guaranteed. All we can do is try out best and feel at peace with our decisions.
Try sitting and writing up an agreement of some sort where you both have defined boundaries. Even just the act of writing it down, proof reading, and modifying at your own pace can bring more inner peace. Then decide if you are comfortable with pursuing these or other options. Good luck!
Best of luck!
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
Thank you for your suggestions. I also offered threesomes as well. He claims that they are likely to happen as he doesn't want to do them with random women as he is afraid I will contract something orally. And my rebuttle was he's ok sticking his dick in random? And his responses was condoms. He claims that doing the threesomes was to satisfy my curiosity and not something he needed or desired.
HappilyMrs 4y ago
Condoms are not 100% against STDs.
pinkdrawings 4y ago
Did you disagree with him? How did he respond?
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
We definitely disagreed. Like I said I'm ok with him having casual hook ups while he is away in Japan. I can't even go see him because the borders are closed for tourists. I did tell him that my boundaries were if he slept with another woman more than once to tell me so I can end things. He agreed. He also said he may never need to sleep with another woman agai. When he is permanently back in the US. So idk I guess at this time I'm just taking it day by day.
aussiedollface2 4y ago
I feel like you need to consider whether you deserve better. Sorry that’s all I have to say re this xo
LateralThinker13 4y ago
This is maybe true for him, maybe not. But marriage is also about fidelity, sacrifice, and compromise. If monogamy is important to you, and variety is important to him, you aren't going to work and no denying your needs will fix this problem.
Truth is, the majority of men aren't like that. Plenty of men bond with their partners, and plenty of men don't need sex outside of marriage. Yours... maybe does. Which maybe means you two are incompatible.
EDIT: Wow, saw your comment below.
If you do, walk away.
Wow. LD relationship with a military divorcee. No odds that will end poorly, none at all, no sir. red flag 1
Do you even understand how much you are denying yourself if you do this? Accepting a behavior is fine; turning a blind eye is saying "I disagree with what you are doing but won't call you out on it". That's corrosive to your integrity and your relationship. WTF.
Which just tells me he doesn't want to be monogamous with you. Red flag 2.
And so he either doesn't trust you, or doesn't trust all women. Either way, red flag 3
Do you ENJOY being one of the plates he spins? Does it fulfill you? Because that's all you are, and from your passive, permissive behavior that's all you'll ever be. Show some self-respect and stand up for what you want, and then prove you deserve it. Most likely with another man, since this guy has more red flags than a matador.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
I am standing up for myself now which is causing strife in our relationship...his only response to my boundaries is that he understands where I am coming from and sex IF he decides to have sex with other wen when we are back together in the states would be nothing more than sex and he keeps emphasizing IF. in his thought process he thinks that I will want him more if other women do. I agree that that may be true to some extent but the more he talks about it, it in turn makes me less attracted to him. And he said he is no longer spinning plates he is exclusive with me and a random hookup is not dating.
CountTheBees 4y ago
Look I'll tell you straight up, he doesn't understand male RP theory well enough to apply it in a LTR. He knows enough to be dangerous but not to be successful.
He is fundamentally failing to understand the difference between a shit test and a comfort test. Or maybe he just hasn't told you you're a plate. Either way he's not treating you like a RP man would treat an LTR.
The reason I know this:
He thinks you're shit testing him and is responding with doubling down!!!! Whereas it is clear to everyone here that you are in fact comfort testing him and when a woman comfort tests a man, if the man wants a relationship with her, he should be soothing her and embodying more beta traits. Instead he's doubling down on alpha traits.
The red flags that u/LateralThinker13 mentioned are also spot on. Coupled with this crappy application of RP theory it's just a mess and you are rightly confused and losing attraction.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
You are right im extremely confused and losing attraction. He has also told me I am not a plate. I havent been a plate since we had our exclusivity talk years ago. And yes he refuses to do anything beta.
therewasguy 4y ago
what beta stuff have you asked him to do?
tbh anyone who denies monogamy is an automatic skip no brainer
this isn't even healthy he has to realize that just risking his health and someone that's important to him longterm is beyond just red flag, it's like he's not even committed for a good life neither for you or himself
i think if you really want this to workout just get professional therapy, obviously he is not going to listen to your perspective his ego is too thick and he sees your comment as less
in my experience that is what it has been for me, even if i mention something useful it doesn't count, but suddenly when someone else mentions it to my so, it's suddenly listened to even when it's wrong, i think maybe they are resentful subconsciously from a past that has nothing to do with you
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
I haven't asked him to do anything beta persay. But he would never exhibit any beta male characteristics. To him he thinks that i would find him less desirable if he was beta. He believes strongly in the alpha fucks beta bucks.
[deleted]
pearlsandstilettos 4y ago
Removed. Advice must be from an RPW perspective.
Mictilacante 4y ago
If you truly love pizza why would you want to eat anything else? It'd be only pizza every meal.
Many men don't play the marriage game, HVM or not. Regardless, for some, monogamy is just simply not for them, and they'll need to determine if that's a deal breaker.
How he approached this topic and if it was discussed prior would be quite telling of how to proceed.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
He has told me he never wants to get married. He was married prior.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
This topic came about because he's military and I saud I was ok with turning a blind eye because we are in a long distance relationship and I understood it would be just sex I didn't think it would be ongoing when he returns back to the states
Pycnostyle 4y ago
Based on your other comments, this dude is flying more red flags than a Chinese New Years parade. But I did want to answer this question for you:
The answer is "it depends" on where the guy is on his life journey. For me, before I got married, I wanted to have all of the fun and variety that I could. But eventually that got a little repetitive and unexciting and I knew that I wanted to start a family. Met a young lady who wanted the same things out of life as I did and had the same values and we got along great and the rest was history.
For the sake of discussion, let's oversimplify HVM vs LVM as follows: a LVM has between 0 to 1 options for partners, whereas a HVM has 2 or more options. If you want a HVM, you have to contend with the fact that he's going to have options other than you. Another hallmark of an HVM is our self-discipline. You don't achieve your life goals without strong self-discipline. You need to be a big part of his story, part of his mission.
For me, I knew that I wanted a family, and that my wife was the right person to raise one with. There's no point in destabilizing that goal, just to bang someone else. Been there, done that.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
He is going on 43 and was married for 16 years in a loveless marriage and he says it's because he was into the blue pill and his marriage failed because of him.
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
He said he may change his mind in the future but why do we need to put a label on things.
Pycnostyle 4y ago
Assuming that nothing changes, is this the relationship that you want to be in? If you're happy, then go for it!
But he definitely deceived you about the vasectomy, and it sounds to me like he's trying to keep your hopes for some type of commitment alive with vague maybe openness at some point in the future, but maybe not. So that's why I'm asking if you're happy with things as is, because if you're not, then you have some soul searching to do.
If you really believe he will ever change, why? What incentive does he have if he's happy as-is?
[deleted] 4y ago
[deleted]
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
What do you mean when you say triangulation?
[deleted] 4y ago
[deleted]
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
I have thought about just doing my own thing as well since I live in the US and he is in Japan and seeing what happens. But I just dont know if I can morally. As far as the toxic game what are you suggesting?
[deleted] 4y ago
[deleted]
Inside-Language-5251 4y ago
I did make some new boundaries. He is agreeing to them however, I do t believe he will be true to his work im realizing he boasts how honest he is but I have recently found out that's not the case at all.