Ever hear of The No True Scotsman fallacy? It is a way of reinterpreting evidence in order to prevent the refutation of one’s position. Proposed counter-examples to a theory are dismissed as irrelevant solely because they are counter-examples, but purportedly because they are not what the theory is about.

The No True Scotsman fallacy involves discounting evidence that would refute a proposition, concluding that it hasn’t been falsified when in fact it has.

  1. John cheats on his wife
  2. No real man (red pill man, alpha) cheats on his wife.

Therefore: John is not a real man (red pill man, alpha)

Therefore: John is not a counter-example to the claim that a real man (red pill man, alpha) cheats on his wife.

I call this the No Real Man Fallacy and it’s gaining traction throughout Red Pill. It’s bullshit. This fallacy is a form of circular argument, with an existing belief being assumed to be true in order to dismiss any apparent counter-examples to it. The existing belief thus becomes unfalsifiable.

Let’s be clear. Red Pill is not endorsing whole sale cheating though it doesn’t vilify it either. Such a move is reserved for the highest levels of dread and even then you have had the FMOFY speech. There are times men are goaded into it because we are proving the point that sex is just that easy to get. If that’s all you want, then get laid. Go do it and stop bothering us.

Making this move at DL11 is not for everyone. Most times things don’t get this far. Divorce happens or she jumps on board the train. It will result in one of two things:

  1. Complete destruction of an already bad marriages
  2. Her utter submission because she knows you can walk out.

There are men here that can attest to either of these outcomes with the use of Dread in this way. It’s been clear that sex is part of the relationship otherwise you are seeking it else where. No one can force someone to have sex yet neither can an adult be forced into celibacy.

Some of the premises used in the No Real Man Fallacy are: you create fear in her (aka negative side of dread), a real man faces his problems head on, a real man would just up and leave.....The list goes on.

The MRP premise has always been at DL11 go get laid. You’ve run the race. She isn’t listening. This step is acknowledging the final end. You are getting fucked you are getting laid. She has no control over that decision. While you can’t make someone have sex (though you can make them pay for your life) you equally can’t force someone into celibacy.

By putting yourself into fictitious beliefs as to what a “real man is and does” you are continuing the same blue pill bullshit that brought you here. Cheat or don’t cheat. That’s your decision. Focusing on this is missing the point. Sex is damn easy to get. Believe me. I am Chad. Yet don’t come here declaring you are a man of your word. I will find many ways in which that isn’t true.

The only place honor and your word exist is when you can afford it. When you have reached the position of a high value man and you can afford to keep your word then you do. Until then you are fighting your way and should not be limiting yourself. Eventually you will find you give your word less and only to things that matter. Constantly giving your word devalues its worth (see the connection?).

I remember when I had my first beer.

I was 18. Fresh out of basic training. My squad leader handed it to me at my first squad party. I was pretty nervous, like looking around for mom. Fuck, I had just graduated basic training, AIT, in my first unit.....I had never had a beer up until then. He looked at me and said:

First beer, eh kid?

Yeah.

Listen. (He pulled the beer away) Don’t let any one force you to drink. If you want to. Do it. If not. Then don’t. Don’t be forced into decisions you don’t want to make but also don’t be afraid to make them.