Perhaps a better analogy (seen here before) is giving a teenager a new car full of booze in the back seat and waiting to see what happens next. I knew a kid who drove drunk and wrecked four cars in his teen years--his dumb parents kept buying him another car!
You have no way of knowing whether she is telling you the truth about her sexual history and religious belief--none--since a rational man will not take what she says at face value. AWALT says when in doubt assume she is lying. Act accordingly.